Internet
giants grilled on China policies
By Stephanie
Kirchgaessner in Washington
Published: February 16 2006 00:14 |
Last updated: February 16 2006
The
giants of the internet industry were
put on the defensive on Wednesday
when US lawmakers compared their
compliance to Chinese censorship
laws with the use of
IBM’s technology in the
organisation of the Holocaust. |
Yahoo,
Google,
Microsoft and
Cisco later responded to stinging criticism of
their business practices – including accusations
that they have “enthusiastically volunteered for
China’s censorship brigade” – saying the issue was
too big for the companies to tackle on their own and
that the US government needed to take a leadership
role.
The international relations sub-committee hearing
on Capitol Hill was not the first time corporate
executives had been taken to task by lawmakers for
their business practices. But the presence at the
hearing of Google and Yahoo, which pride themselves
on facilitating the exchange of information around
the world, and who have never before come under such
harsh scrutiny, underscores that congressional
pressure is building on the groups to take action to
address concerns such as China’s human rights record.
Google on Wednesday admitted that its decision to
enter the Chinese market and censor the results of
its Google.cn website was “reasonable, though we
cannot be sure it will ultimately be proven to be
the best one”.
“If we determine that we are unable to achieve
the objectives [we have set out], we will not
hesitate to reconsider our approach to China,” said
Elliot Schrage, vice-president of global affairs at
Google.
Mr Schrage and other executives were at times
left speechless under the relentless questioning of
California congressman Tom Lantos, a Hungarian-born
Holocaust survivor who asked each of the companies
whether they felt “ashamed” and whether they would
agree to discriminate against women if asked to by a
repressive regime.
“Your abhorrent activities in China are a
disgrace. I simply do not understand how your
corporate leadership sleeps at night,” Mr Lantos
said.
Dana Rohrabacher, a Republican legislator,
emphasised the Chinese government’s persecution of
minorities in China, and introduced Peter Yuan Li, a
Chinese-born American who was beaten in his home in
Georgia this month. Mr Li has accused Chinese agents
of being behind the attack because of the work he
has done as a software engineer trying to get
controversial websites through Chinese firewalls. In
a Financial Times interview, the Falun Gong
practitioner described being subjected to a
ferocious beating at his home by Chinese and Korean
speaking men who stole two laptops and his home
telephone.t.