China: Religious Repression of
Uighur Muslim
1 Apr 2005 16:20:10 GMT
Source: Human Rights Watch
(New York, April 12, 2005) -- The Chinese
government is directing a crushing campaign of
religious repression against China's Muslim Uighurs in
the name of anti-separatism and counter-terrorism,
Human Rights Watch and Human Rights in China said in
a new report today. The 114-page report,
Devastating Blows: Religious Repression of Uighurs in
Xinjiang, is based on previously undisclosed
Communist Party and government documents, as well as
local regulations, official newspaper accounts, and
interviews conducted in Xinjiang. It unveils for the
first time the complex architecture of law, regulation,
and policy in Xinjiang that denies Uighurs religious
freedom, and by extension freedom of association,
assembly, and expression. Chinese policy and law
enforcement stifle religious activity and thought even
in school and at home. One official document goes so
far as to say that "parents and legal guardians may
not allow minors to participate in religious
activities."
"The worldwide campaign against terrorism has given
Beijing the perfect excuse to crack down harder than
ever in Xinjiang," said Brad Adams, Asia director for
Human Rights Watch. "Other Chinese enjoy a growing
freedom to worship, but the Uighurs, like the Tibetans,
find that their religion is being used as a tool of
control."
The Uighurs, a Turkish-speaking minority of some 8
million people, whose traditional homeland lies in the
oil-rich Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region in
northwest China, have become increasingly fearful for
their cultural survival and traditional way of life in
the face of an intensive internal migration drive that
has witnessed the arrival of more than 1.2 million
ethnic Chinese settlers over the past decade. Many
Uighurs desire greater autonomy than is currently
allowed; some wish for a separate state, although
there is little recent evidence of violent rebellion.
Highly intrusive religious control extends to
organized religious activities, religious
practitioners, schools, cultural institutions,
publishing houses, and even to the personal appearance
and behavior of Uighur individuals. State authorities
politically vet all imams on a regular basis and
require "self-criticism" sessions; impose surveillance
on mosques; purge schools of religious teachers and
students; screen literature and poetry for political
allusions; and equate any expression of
dissatisfaction with Beijing's policies with "separatism"
?a state security crime under Chinese law that can
draw the death penalty.
At its most extreme, peaceful activists practicing
their religion in ways that the Party and government
deem unacceptable are arrested, tortured, and at times
executed. The harshest punishments are saved for those
accused of involvement in so-called separatist
activity, which officials increasingly term "terrorism"
for domestic and external consumption.
At a more mundane level, Uighurs face harassment in
their daily lives. Celebrating religious holidays,
studying religious texts, or showing one's religion
through personal appearance are strictly forbidden at
state institutions, including schools. The Chinese
government vets who can be a cleric, what version of
the Koran is acceptable, where religious gatherings
may be held, and what may be said.
"Uighurs are seen by Beijing as an
ethno-nationalist threat to the Chinese state," said
Sharon Hom, executive director of Human Rights in
China. "As Islam is perceived as underpinning Uighur
ethnic identity, China has taken draconian steps to
smother Islam as a means of subordinating Uighur
nationalist sentiment."
Documents obtained and interviews conducted by
Human Rights Watch and Human Rights in China reveal a
multi-tiered system of surveillance, control, and
suppression of Uighur religious activity. As Xinjiang
Party Secretary Wang Lequan has stressed, the "major
task" facing the authorities in Xinjiang is to "manage
religion and guide it in being subordinate to the
central task of economic construction, the unification
of the motherland, and the objective of national unity."
The new report details:
- the current regulations governing religious
activities in Xinjiang;
- a manual for government and Party cadres on
implementing policy on minority religious affairs,
circulated internally in 2000, that elaborates many
of the repressive practices subsequently codified in
the regulations;
- regulations prohibiting the participation of
minors in any religious activity;
- documents acknowledging vast increases in the
number of Uighurs; imprisoned or held
administratively for alleged religious and state
security offenses, including through the discredited
reeducation through labor system; and
- regulations detailing how religious and ethnic
minority matters come to be classified as "state
secrets."
Some of these documents are made public for the
first time. A selection can be found in the report's
appendices.
"These documents are deemed extremely sensitive and
therefore restricted to internal Party and government
circulation," said Adams. "They are used arbitrarily
to create a legal basis to target Uighurs and to
create fear of meeting together, talking about
problems that Uighurs face, or expressing cultural
identity in an independent manner."
An official Manual regulating religion in Xinjiang
contains catch-all "offenses" that allow the
authorities to deny religious freedom under virtually
any pretext, such as using religion "to carry out
other activities that are harmful to the good order of
society," or "to breed separatist elements and
reactionary backbone elements." It goes on to say that:
Any item to be published [including news and
articles] related to research and appraisal of Islamic
religion must uphold the Marxist point of view of
religion, and use the yardstick of the Party's and the
government's religious policies and regulations.
An article co-signed by the vice-director of the
Xinjiang Reeducation through Labor Bureau reveals that
as of 2001 almost half the detainees in reeducation
camps are there for "[belonging to] illegal
organizations and [engaging in] illegal religious
activities."
"Religious regulation in Xinjiang is so pervasive,
that it creates a legal net that can catch just about
anyone the authorities want to target," said Hom.
Devastating Blows also details how two specific
regulations––revealed here for the first time––establish
a draconian ban against unauthorized disclosure of
information regarding almost any national minority or
religious matter or policy, even if unrelated to
national security.
The report also explains how China is using the
events of September 11, 2001 and the subsequent "war
on terror" as a cover for targeting Uighurs. Although
repressive religious policies in Xinjiang predate
September 11, the government now asserts that it faces
an Islamic-inspired separatist movement with links to
international terrorist groups and Al-Qaeda. But
Beijing has undermined its credibility by erasing
distinctions between violent acts and peaceful dissent.
Using Orwellian logic, officials now claim that
terrorists pose as peaceful activists. As the Xinjiang
party secretary said:
Xinjiang's independence elements have changed their
combat tactics since the September 11 incident. They
have focused on attacking China on the ideological
front instead of using their former frequent practice
of engaging in violent terrorist operations. Literary
means and arts and literature are being used to "distort
historical facts…instead of engaging in violent
terrorist operations?
Human Rights Watch and Human Rights in China called
on the international community to press China to
repeal these regulations and end their policies and
practices of discrimination against Uighurs. The
organizations also stressed the need to challenge
Chinese assertions that all separatists are criminals
or are connected to international terror networks.
"No country should return to China any Uighurs
claimed by China to be involved in terrorism,
separatism or other criminal acts," said Adams. "Given
China's past record, there is every reason to fear
they will be tortured or even subjected to the death
penalty once back in China."
Excerpts from Devastating Blows
"We must strengthen the management of religious
public figures, and be sure that they are politically
qualified. This is a demand of the first order.
Political qualifications are the following: an ardent
love for the motherland, support for Communist Party
leaders and the socialist system, opposition to
national splittism and illegal religious activities,
the defense of national unity and the unification of
the motherland, and a conscious compliance with the
nation's laws and policies…We must implement a
reinforcement of the management of the places of
religious activity and the content of the texts?
Xinjiang Party Secretary, Wang Lequan
"This is a Uighur school and we are mostly Uighurs
working here. But neither at home nor at work are you
supposed to talk to the children about religion. You
just talk about it and it is illegal. Even with my own
son, I am not supposed to tell him about Islam. How
can this be possible?"
"Some students who are studying in our school,
namely your children, have not been concentrating
fully on their studies as they have been praying and
keeping the fast and becoming involved in some
religious activities, thus disobeying Document No. 5
1996 of the Autonomous Region Education Commission
which says that students should not participate in
religious activities (praying, keeping the fast and
other religious activities) and also disobeying our
school rules."
"In my home village, the militia regularly comes to
check villagers. They come during the night, searching
house by house, and if they find religious material
they take you for questioning. They say it's "illegal
religious publications." My father is a simple farmer,
what does he know if his Koran is illegal or not?"
"That is how it has gone with me, and mind you I am
not what you would call a fervent Muslim. Only during
class I would often talk about religious songs. They
are widespread; it is absurd that you are not allowed
to speak about it. It is an important part of our
musical history and tradition, which is what I was
supposed to teach. But then, the next term they [the
school authorities] tell me not enough students
enrolled in my course, which is not true. So I have
not taught for a year now. They have not dismissed me
and I should not complain too much because I still eat
the bread of the Communist Party, but I just walk
around campus or sit at my desk. It is a total waste,
but it is better not to talk about it."
Uighur professor at a higher education
institution in Xinjiang banned from teaching local
musical traditions.
"I managed to set up some business with other
relatives, and that is my pride. I was working before
in an office, dealing with food supplies for schools,
but then they said: "No beards allowed in here. Not
even mustaches." I thought how can they tell me what I
do with myself? This is our tradition, nobody's
business. So I had an opportunity to leave, and I left.
But if you cannot find another job, in the private
sector, you either shave or starve."
During "exchange of experience" sessions clerics
are asked to address the other participants with
precise accounts of "difficulties" or "incidents" they
have encountered in their work. For instance, an imam
will describe how "illegal" religious classes were
held, or how the mosque used some "illegal" religious
book. They may also relate how they failed to warn the
authorities about "elements" that were "agitating," or
about inviting a cleric from another area without
prior authorization. Clerics also have to admit
personal errors and how they have nurtured "incorrect"
ideas. They also have to point out examples of such
erroneous actions on the part of other members of the
group.
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/12/international/asia/12china.html
|