|
The
Uighurs
-
Erkin Alptekin
Intrduction
The
Uighurs are the native people of Eastern
Turkestan, also known as Xinjiang Uighur
Autunomous Region. The latest Chinese census
gives the present population of the Uighurs as
slightly over 6 million(l) There are also
500,OOO Uighurs in Western Turkestan, known as
Uzbekistan, Kazakistan, Kirgizistan,
Turkmenistan and Tajikistan(2). Almost 150,000
Uighurs have thier homes in Pakistan,
Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Western
Europe and the United States(3).
Chinese
sources indicate that the Uighurs are the direct
descendents of the Huns(4). The Huns are the
forefathers of the Turkic people.
The
name "Uighur" is mentioned in the
chronicles of the Chinese Han dynasty (206 B.C.-220
A.D.), Wei dynasty (265-289 A.D.), Tang dynasty
(618-906 A.D.), and Sung dynasty (906-960 A.D)
(5).
Although
they were known under different names such as
Wei-ho, Gaoche or Yuan-ho in different periods
of history, there is no doubt that these people
were Uighurs(6) Gaoche means "High Cart"
tribes(7) To this day the big wheeled nepe or
high cart is a characteristic sight in some
cities in southern Eastern Turkestan. Even today
the Chinese call the Uighurs Wei Wu Er.
Ancient
Greek, Iranian and Chinese sources placed the
Uighurs with their tribes and sub-tribes in the
vast area between the west banks of the Yellow
River in the east, Eastern Turkestan in the
west, and in the Mongolian steppe in the
northeseast as early as 300 B.C.(8)
After
210 B.C. the Uighurs played important roles in
Hun (220 B.C.-386 A.D.),Tabgach (386-534 A.D.)
and Kok Turk (552-744 A.D.) Turkic empires which
were established in Central Asia.(9)
In
670, 688, 692 A.D. the Uighurs, the Kok Turks
and the Shato joined the Tibetan armies in their
military expeditions in capturing the Chinese
strongholds in north and northeast Central Asia.(1O)
Political
History
After
the fall of the Kok Turk Empire in Central Asia,
the Uighurs established their first state in
Mongolia in 744, with the city Karabalgasun, on
the banks of the Orkhun River, as its capital.
The
founder of this Uighur state was Kutluk Bilge
Kul Khan. In 747 he was succeeded by his son
Moyunchur, a powerful leader who subdued other
Turkic clans, consolidated the monarchy, and
extended hls rule in the north to Lake Baykal,
in the east to Kansu and in the southwest to
Eastern Turkestan.(11)
It
so happened that just as the Uighurs became
united and strong, the Chinese Tang dynasty
under Hsuan-tsung (712-756 A.D.) was undergoing
a sharp decline.In 751 a Chinese army was
disastrously defeated in the battle of Talas
River by the Arabs and their allies. In the same
year, a Chinese invasion of the Nan-chao to the
southwest was thwarted with appalling losses to
the Chinese; and a Chinese force under An Lu
Shan was defeated by the Khitan in the northeast.
These disasters were but the prelude to a much
more fearful catastrophe - the rebellion of the
former trusted minister An Lu Shan which broke
out in 755.
It
was under these circumstances that the Uighurs
were invited by Su-tsung, the Hsuan-tsungs
successor, to send armies to help the Chinese.
In this event the Uighur forces played a key
role in the recapture of both Changan and
Lu-yang in 757. The Uighurs did not hesitate to
exploit the Tang dynastic debt owed them, by
acts of appalling pillage. The chinese emperor
agreed to pay 200,000 rolls of silk as tribute
annually to the Uighurs and granted the Uighur
Khan one of his daughters in marriage(l2). She
was the first of the three princesses of Chinese
imperial family to become an Uighur khatun in
the period 744-840 A.D.(13)
Moyunchur
Khan died in 759 and was succeeded by his son
Bugu Khan. During his reign, the Uighurs reached
the apex of their power. They began with China,
which engaged in forced trade of Uighur horses
for Chinese silk - an exchange which was noted
frequently in Chinese sources before 829.
In
762 Bugu Khan went to the Middle Kingdom where
he helped the Tang dynasty in the final battles
against the rebellion which had racked it for so
long.
In
779, Bugu Khan was killed by his first cousin
and chief minister Baga Tarkan. Bugu Khan's
Sogdian allies and advisers had wanted him to
take advantage of the death in 779 of Emperor
Tai-tsung and the state mourning involved in it,
to undertake an invasion of China. Bugu Khan
agreed to do this. His first cousin Baga Tarkan
opposed the plan; and when he saw the tide
turning against him, murdered Bugu Khan and set
himself on the throne. Baga Tarkan, believed
that at this stage China could have been
conquered by the Uighurs. But he did not believe
that the Uighurs would be able to preserve their
national identity if they once conquered China,
a vast and populous country even then.
After
the death of Baga Tarkan in 789 and especially
after that of his successor, Kulug Bilge Khan in
790, Uighur power and prestige declined.
In
795, the rule of the Uighur state passed to
another Uighur clan. Under this new clan the
Uighurs became more and more steeped in religion,
which softened them and planted seeds of
advanced culture which characterized the Uighurs
of later ages. The most important ruler of this
clan was Kutluk Bilge Khan, whose successful
military exploits, both before and during his
reign, are reported in the Karabalgasun
inscriptions(14.) He did not succeed, however,
in restoring the Uighur empire to its former
power.
With
Kutluk Bilge Khan's death in 805, the forces of
disintegration of the Uighur state gathered
momentum. War broke out abroad with the powerful
Kirgiz neighbours to the north; while at home,
court intrigue eroded the power of the royal
family; rebellions broke out, and, to add to
everything, a bad season and severe winter in
839 killed much of the livestock upon which the
Uighur economy was so dependent. In 840, the
Kirgiz, invited by a rebel chief, attacked the
tottering state, killed the khan, and took the
capital.
This
first part of Uighur political history shows the
Uighurs as the protectors of the Chinese empire
for almost a century. On the other hand, the
relationship was not really a friendly one.
There was abiding resentment on the Chinese side.
The reason was that the Middle Kingdom was
obliged to be protected by a "barbarian"
people.
Although
the Uighurs lost over the centuries so many of
the features of their entirely nomadic past, the
Chinese continued to regard them as uncivilized
barbarians as they did other peoples. The
Uighurs, for their part, never gave the Chinese
the respect which the latter would have liked
(15).
After
the fall of the first Uighur empire, a group of
Uighurs emigrated to the west banks of the
Yellow River in Kansu; a second group emigrated
via Yetti Su to the southern part of Khan Tengri
or Tian Shan in Eastern Turkestan; the third and
the largest group of Uighurs emigrated to the
northern part of Khan Tengri where their
ancestors were still living(16).
The
Kan-Chou Uighur Kingdom
The
Uighurs who emigrated to the west banks of the
Yellow river in Kansu established a kingdom in
850 known as the Kan-chou Uighur Kingdom.
This
kingdom never became a major power, but the
Chinese had great respect for it as seen from
the Chinese court praise of the Kan-chou Uighur
King when an Uighur and a Tibetan ambassadors
visited the Chinese capital in 911(17).
Nevertheless,
this kingdom was absorbed in 1228 by the Tankuts
who established a state in the area known as
Western Hsia.
Several
thousands of these Uighurs still live in the
Kansu area under the name Sarik Uighurs or
Yellow Uighurs, preserving their old Uighur
tongue.
The
Karakhoja Uighur Kingdom
The
Uighurs who emigrated to the northern part of
Khan Tengri in Eastern Turkestan established the
second Uighur Kingdom in 846 known as Karakhoja
Uighur Kingdom near the present day city of
Turfan(18). The Chinese recognized this kingdom
and sent Wang Yen de in 981 to Karakhoja as
their ambassador(19). Wang Yen De stayed in
Karakhoja for three years.
The
Karakhanid Uighur Kingdom
The
Uighurs who settled in the southern part of Khan
Tengri, established the Karakhanid Kingdom in
840 with the support of other Turkic clans like
the Karluks, the Turgish and the Basmil, with
Kashgar as their capital(20).
In
934, during the rule of Satuk Bughra Khan, the
Karakhanids embraced the Islamic religion(21).
Thus, in the territory of Eastern Turkestan two
Uighur kingdoms were set up: the Karakhanids,
who were Muslims, and the Karakhoja Uighurs who
were Buddhists.
The
Islamic kingdom was overrun by the Karakhitays
in 1124. The Karakhitays are also known as the
Western Liao. They were a mixture of Mongol,
Turkic and Tunguz people. Thus the Buddhist
Uighur Kingdom became vassals of the Karakhitays.
In
1218 the Buddhist Uighur Kingdom was voluntarily
confederated with Chengiz Khan against their
common enemy, the Karakhitays whom they
defeated(22). The Uighur King Barchuk was
accepted "graciously" by Chengiz Khan
as his "fifth son The Buddhist Uighurs
maintained their sovereignty in the north and
Mahmud Yalvach, a Muslim Uighur was appointed to
the administration in the south(24).
Chengiz
Khan died in 1227, and his empire was divided
among his four sons.Chagatay inherited Western
and Eastern Turkestan. Like his father; he did
not interfere with the internal affairs of
Eastern Turkestan. After his death Turkestan was
divided into two parts again by rival khans in a
power struggle to succeed Chagatay. After a
bloody struggle Timur succeeded to the
Chagatay's throne in Western Turkestan in 1368.
The
rule of the Muslim part of Eastern Turkestan
passed into the hands of Khizir Khoja, who
staged an invasion of the Buddhist Uighur
Kingdom in the north in 1397 and brought them
under his rule. After that the lslamic religion
also spread among the Buddhist Uighurs(26.) This
Islamic Uighur Kingdom of Eastern Turkestan
maintained its independence until 1759(27).
The
Manchus who set up a huge empire in China,
invaded the Uighur Kingdom in 1759 and dominated
it until 1862. During this period the Uighurs
revolted 42 times against the Manchu rule with
the purpose of regaining their independence(28)
In the last revolt of 1863, the Uighurs were
successful in expelling the Manchus from their
motherland, and founded an independent kingdom
under the leaderhsip of Yakub Bey. This kingdom
was recognized by the Ottoman Empire, Tsarist
Russia and Great Britain(29). But for fear of
Tsarist expansion into Eastern Turkestan, Great
Britain persuaded the Manchu court to conquer
Eastern Turkestan. The money for the Manchu
invasion forces was granted by British
banks(30).
Large
forces under the overall command of General Zho
Zhung Tang attacked Eastern Turkestan in 1876.
After this invasion, Eastern Turkestan was given
the name Xinjiang or Sinkiang which means
"New Dominion" or "New Territory"
and it was annexed into the territory of the
Manchu empire on 18 November 1884(31).
In
1911, the Nationalist Chinese, under the
leadership of Dr. Sun Yat Sen, overthrew Manchu
rule and established a republic.
The
Uighurs, who also wanted to free themselves from
foreign domination, staged several uprisings
against the Nationalist Chinese rule during this
period. Twice, in 1933 and 1944, the Uighurs
were successful in setting up an independent
Islamic Eastern Turkestan republic(32). But
these independent Islamic Republics were
overthrown by the military intervention and
political intrigues of the Soviet Union. It was
in fact the Soviet Union that proved a deterrent
to the Uighur independence movement throughout
this period.
In
1949 the Nationalist Chinese were defeated by
the Chinese communists. After that, Eastern
Turkestan fell under Chinese communist rule.
Uighur language, culture and civilization
The
Uighurs were far more advanced than the other
Turkic peoples because they lived along the Silk
Route which served as a route of commercial,
cultural and religious exchanges throughout
history.
At
the end of the 19th century and the first few
decades of the 20th century, scientific and
archaeological expeditions to the region along
the Silk Route in Eastern Turkestan led to the
discovery of numerous Uighur cave temples,
monastery ruins, wall paintings, miniatures,
statues, frescoes, valuable manuscripts,
documents and books. Members of the expedition
from Great Britain, Sweden, Russia, Germany,
France and Japan were amazed by the art treasure
they found there, and soon detailed reports
captured the attention of interested public
around the world. The relics of these rich
Uighur cultural remnants brought back by Sven
Kidin of Sweden, Aurel Stein of Great Britain,
Albert von Lecoq of Germany, Paul Pelliot of
France, Langdon Warner of United States and
Count Ottani of Japan can be seen today in the
museums of Berlin, London, Paris, Tokyo,
Leningrad and even in the Museum of Central
Asian Antiquities in New Delhi (33). The
manuscripts, documents and the books discovered
in Eastern Turkestan proved that the Uighurs had
a very high degree of civilization compared to
the Europeans of the Middle Ages (34).
Uighur
Language
The
main language spoken in Eastern Turkestan is
Uighur. Uighur represents one of the dialects of
the widely diffused Turkic language family.
Among Western linguists, the term "Eastern
Turkish" is also widely in use for Uighur.
There is, of course, a great difference between
the old Uighur and the present one. Closely
related to the Uighur is Uzbek. But the Turkic
inhabitants of Kazakhistan, Kirgizistan,
Turkmenistan, Tataristan, Azerbaijan and even
Turkey have almost no difficulty communicating
with each other.
Uighur
Script
Throughout
the centuries, the Uighurs used three kinds of
scripts. When they were confederated wilh the
Kok Turks in the 6th and 71h centuries, they
used the Orkhum script, which was actually a Kok
Turk invention(35). Later, the Uighurs dropped
this script (36) and and adopted their own
script which became to be known as the Uighur
Script. This script was used for almost 800
years not only by the Uighurs, but also by other
Turkic peoples, the Mongols, and by the Manchus
in the early stage of their rule in China(37).
As the Mongols did not have their own written
language, the Uighur script was adopted by
Chengiz Khan's empire for all sorts of
correspondence(38). Guyuk Khan's (1246-1248)
letter to the Pope of that time was also written
in the Uighur script(39). The Uighurs were also
instrumental in shaping Mongol administration,
which was formidable by any standards. They
manned Mongol chanceries and, probably because
of their knowledge of languages, were often
charged with visiting foreigners. Both Plano
Carpini and Rubruck mention them. The Uighurs
also emerged as teachers of the royal family,
governers in China, ambassadors in Rome, today's
Istanbul, and Baghdad, scholars in Tebriz and
officers in the army (40) . After embracing
Islam, the Uighurs adopted the Arabic alphabet,
but common usage of the Arabic script came only
in the llth century.
Uighur
Literature
The
first Uighur literary works were mostly
translations of Buddhist and Manichaeist
religious books. Besides, during the expeditions
some narrative, poetic and epic works were also
discovered. Some of these works have been
translated into German, English, Russian and
Turkish(41). After embracing Islam Uighurs
continued to preserve their cultural dominance
in Central Asia.
In
this period hundreds of Uighur scholars, well
known in the world, emerged. Hundreds of
valuable books were written. One hundred and
thirty of these important works were discovered
later. Some of these books are in the Leningrad
National Museum (42). Among these works, Uighur
scholar Yusuf Has Hacip's book, Kutaku Bilik,
Mahmud Kashgari's Divan-i Lugat-it Turk, Ahmet
Yukneki's, Atabetul Hakayik, Bakshi Herevis,
Uighur Mihrajname, Abdulfazil Muhammed Omer's,
Esserruh Minelshah, Mavlana Hashim Yarkendi's,
Keshf-ul Israr, Mavlana Muhammed Sadreddin
Karakashi's, Mujmet-ul Ahkam are very famous.
All these works were written in Ihe 10th, llth
and 12th centuries.Yusuf Has Hajip's Kutatku
Bilik was written in 1069-1070. It is a unique
example of a work that explains social, cultural
and political lives of the Uighurs during this
period. Mahmud Kashgari's Divan-i Lugat-it Turk,
which was also written in this age, bears
knowledge as to the dialects of various Turkic
peoples living at that time. It also gives
information about the dialectical differences,
their social upbringings, their customs as well
as the regions they inhabited. The author of
this encyclopedic dictionary wandered amidst all
of Turkic peoples before he compiled his work,
studied all the data and thus provided a sound
academic basis. Mahmud Kashgari's Divan-i
Lugat-it Turk is one of the main source for
Turkic studies in the world today. Iman Hussein
Halef of Kashgar was the first Turkic Muslim
scholar in Eastern Turkestan who translated the
meaning of the Holy Koran into the Uighur
language in the 12th century(43). The Islamic
civilization that evolved among the Uighurs also
gave birth to great Turkic Muslim scholars and
writers, such as Iman Bukhari, Tirmizi,
Samerqandi, Biruni, Farabi, Ibn-i Sina, Abu
Mashhari, Zimahshari, Ulugbek and Alishir Nevai.
Religion
Prior
to Islam, like most of the Turkic peoples in
Central Asia, the Uighurs believed in religions
like Shamanism, Buddhism and Manicheism.
Buddhism entered Eastern Turkestan at the
beginning of our era(44).. It quickly spread
among the Turkic peoples of Central Asia, but it
was the uygurs who founded Buddhism in Central
Asia.
The
ruins of the famous monasteries known as the
Ming Oy or the Thousand Buddhas built by the
Uighurs can still be seen in the cities of Kucha,
Turfan and Tunhuang, where the Kan-Chao Uighurs
lived.
The
Uighur Kin Kul Bilge Khan (685-712) ordered a
Buddhist monastery to be built in the city of
Bay in Eastern Turkestan(45).
In
the city of Kucha, there were more than 50
Buddhist temples, libraries and welfare programs
for the support of the poor(46). In the city of
Hoten there were 14 large monasteries without
counting the smaller ones(47)
When
Uighur king Bugu Khan travelled to China in 762,
he met some Manichean priests. They succeeded in
converting him to their religion and four of
these priests returned with him to Karabalgasun.
Shortly after, Bugu Khan imposed Manicheism as
the state religion(48). This was a political
step rather than a religious one. He hoped, by
adopting this characteristically Sogdan religion,
to direct the future of his people away from the
cultural influence of the Chinese who were also
Buddhists(49)
The
Uighurs embraced Islam in 934, during the reign
of Satuk Bughra Khan. He was the first Turkic
ruler who embraced Islam in Central Asia. At
this time instead of temples, mosques were built.
Almost 300 mosques were built only in the city
of Kashgar. Among them, most famous are Ihe Azna
Mosque, built in 12th century, Idgah Mosque
built in 15th century and Appak Khoja Mosque,
built in the 18th century. The Idgah mosque can
accomodate 5000 Muslims. In the city of Kashgar
alone their were 6 big Madrasahs. The Mesudi
Library, built in the 15th century, had a
collection of almost 200,000 books(51).
Hundreds
of MusIim students from various parts of the
Islamic World came to Kashgar to study.
Uighur
Economy
The
Uighurs adopted a sedentary life style earlier
than the other Turkic peoples. Thus, the Uighurs
knew how to cultivate land as early as 2nd
century A.D. The Uighurs were engaged in a much
more advanced agriculture by the 7th century.
They raised wheat, maize, vegetables and fruits.
Water melons that the Uighurs raised in Turfan
weighed some 30 pounds(52). The fields were
irrigated with water brought from far distances
by the "kariz" or "water canals"
built by the Uighurs. These "kariz"
are still in use in Eastern Turkestan today.
Cotton
was one of the principle local products of
commercial value. It was the Uighurs who
familiarized the Mongols with its use. The
Mongol word for cotton is Uighur(53) Cotton and
products manufactured from cotton contributed to
the prosperity of the region(54).
Another
product of commercial value was carpets. The
cities of Hoten, Kashgar and Turfan were carpet
manufacturing centers. These three cities are
still famous for their carpet products. Uighur
medicine
The
Uighurs had an extensive knowledge of medicine
and medical practice. Sung dynasty (906-960)
sources indicate that an Uighur physician,
namely, Nanto, travelled to China, and brought
with him many kinds of medicines not known to
the Chinese(55). The Tatar scholar Rashid
Rahmeti Arat has written two valuable books in
German entitled Zur Heilkunder der Uighuren or
Medical Practices of the Uighurs in 1930 and
1932, relying on Uighur documents discovered in
Eastern Turkestan. In his book Arat gives
important information on Uighur medicine and
medical treatment. Among the documents he
studied he found a very important sketch of a
man with an explanation of acupuncture. Relying
on this document, some Western scholars claims
that acupunture was not a Chinese, but a Turkic
invention and that the Uighurs perfected the
method(56).
In
other fields such as architecture, art, music
and printing the Uighurs were also far more
advanced. Western scholars who have studied
Uighur history, culture and civilization have
often expressed a high estimation of the
cultural level of the Uighurs. For instance,
Ferdinand de Sassure has written: "Those
who preserved the language and written culture
of Central Asia were the Uighurs(57)".
Albert von Lecoq, "The Uighur language and
script contributed to the enrichment of
civilizations of the other peoples in Central
Asia. Compared to the Europen as of that time
the Uighurs were far more advanced. Documents
discovered in Eastern Turkestan prove that an
Uighur farmer could write down a contract, using
legal terminology. How many European farmers
could have done that at the same period? This
shows the extent of Uighur civilization of that
time(58). Laszlo Rasonyi: "The Uighurs knew
how to print books centuries before Gutenberg
invented his press(59)", Wolfram Eberhard:
"In the Middle Ages, the Chinese poetry,
literature, theatre, music and painting were
greatly influenced by the Uighurs(60)".
Chinese envoys such as Hsuan Chang, Wang Yen De
and Chang Chun who travelled through Eastern
Turkestan between the 7th and 13th centuries
reported that they were impressed by the high
degree of Uighur power, prestige and culture
found in the Uighur kingdom(61).
This
Uighur power, prestige and culture which
dominated Central Asia for more than a thousand
years went into a steep decline after the Manchu
invasion of Eastern Turkestan and during the
rule of Communist Chinese.
Notes:
- Beijinp
Review, 21.5.1983
2. Kommunizin
Tugi, 19.12.1968; Ibid., 20.2.1968; Ibid.,
12.2.1970
3. Estimates of the Eastern Turkestan Refugee
Committee in Istanbul.
4. I. Kafesoglu, Turk Dunyasi El Kitabi, Ankara,
1976, p. 725
5. Jack Cheng, Shinkiang Story, New York, 1977,
p. 96.
6.Ibid.
7. Ibid.
8. Riznur, Turk Tarihi, lstanbul 1972, p. 57;
Kebirov, Kommunizim Tugi,
13.2.1973; 1. Kafesoglu, Ibid., p. 706 - 797, A.
Caferoglu, Eski Turkee
Sozlugu, Istanbul, 1968, p. 8
9. Laszlo Rasonyi, Tarihte Turluk, Ankara, 1971,
pp. 105, 107
10. H.E. Richardson, Tibet and Its History,
London, 1962, p. 29
11. Collin Mackarras, The Uyghur Empire,
Canberra, 1968, p. 6
12. Ibid., p. 7
13. Ibid., p. 10
14. Ibid., p. 7
15. Ibid., p. 9
16. I. Kafesoglu, op. cit., p. 726
17. Ibid., p. 727
18. Riza Nur, op. cit., p. 358
19. Von Gabian, Das Leben in uighurischen
Konigreich von Quoco, Wiesbaden,
1973, p. 19
20. Riza Nur, op. cit., p. 348
21. M.E. Bugra, Dogu Turkestan Tarahi, Istanbul,
1952, p. 12
22. Von Gabain, op. cit., p. 29
23. Ibid., p. 30
24. M.E. Bugra, op. cit., p. 14
25. lbid
26. Ibid. p.15
27. Fan Wen Lan, A Short General History of
China, Shanghai, 1917, p. 729
28. M.E. Bugra, Chinese Policy, Istanbul, 1954,
p. 25
29, I.Y. Alptekin, Dogu Turkestan Davasi,
Istanbul, 1973, pp. 12(,, 127, 128
30. Owen Lattimore, Pivot of Asia, Boston, 1950,
p. 32
31. Ibid., p. 50
32. LY. Alptekan, op. cit., pp. 154, 175
33. Owen Lattimore, op. cit., p. 223
34. Albert von Licoq, Turan, Berlin, 1980, p.
452
35. Emel Esin, Islamiyetten Onceki Tiirk Tarihi,
Istanbul, 1978, p. 117
36. Ibid
37. Ibid
38. Laszlo Rasony, op. cit., p. 112
39. Ibid
40.Ibid
41. Bradford D. Kellehar, Along the Ancient Silk
Road, New York, 1982
42. Kebiro, Kommunizim Tugi, 6.8.1970
43. Emel Esin, op. cit.
44. Gevin Hamley, Central Asia, New York, 1969,
p. 35
45. Ismet Parmaksiz, Genal Tarih, Ankara, 1976,
p. 330
46. Denis Sinor, lnner Asia, Bloomington, 1969,
p. 330
47. Peter Hopkirk, Foreign Devils on the Silk
Road, London, 1980, p. 25
48. Collin Mackarras. op. cit., p. 7
49.Ibid, p.8
50. S.M. Kasgarli, Akademi Mecmuasi, Istanbul,
Oct. 1985, No. 4
51. Ibid; Al Abudi, Shark U1 Vasat, 12.8.1983
52. Denis Sinor, op. cit., p. 120
53. Ibid
54. Ibid
55. Suheyl Unver, Uygurlarda Tababet, Istanbul,
1936, p. 87
56. Yakup Bugra, Tercuman, 6.6.1984
57. A. Caferoglu, op. cit., p. 1
58. A. Suheyl Unver, Uygurlarda Tababet,
Istanbul, 1936, pp. 4,5,6
59. Laszlo Rasony; op. cit., pp. 112-113
60. Wolfram Eber Hard, Cin Tarihi, Istanbul.
1947, p. 116
61. Denis Sinor, op. cit., p. 119
- Journal Institute of Muslim Minority Affairs:
Vol. 8:2, July 1987
|